Modding: The Relationship Between Gamers and Developers

With the upcoming release of GTA V for PC and next-gen consoles, most gamers would not pay too much attention the port of a last generation game.  However, a new addition has sparked renewed interest in the game, making it a must buy for many gamers.  The new port adds a first-person point of view to the traditional over the shoulder look.  This is the first time Rockstar has taken the lead in adding FPS to its GTA franchise.  Yet, amongst gamers, this is not the first time that FPS (First-Person Shooter) has been added to GTA. Years ago, videos and files emerged showing GTA IV in as an FPS .  These videos didn’t come from Rockstar, though, but from people who loved playing the game.  These people are known as “modders.”

Modders do simply what the name implies: modify video gaming code to alter the structure, look, or gameplay of the video game.  These modifications are simply known as “mods.”  It allows games to live second lives and take on new looks.  In some instances, it even makes games run better.  Modding games has existed as long as games have existed.  From Doom to Skyrim, gamers have always been cracking open the code to changing it.  However, the legal aspect of modding has always been murky.

When dealing with modding, companies have been wary to give their blessing.  Dice and Blizzard have been wary of modders and often refuse to allow access to the source code for the game.  An often cited issue is where copyright laws come in conflict with the distribution of mod packets.  Copyright laws allow the exclusivity and protection of certain works.  Some argue that those works include video games and the stories within them. Rewriting those stories and codes within could potentially breach copyright laws.  Furthermore, it could take control of the game out of developer hands and place them in the hands of gamers.  The result can be a loss of control of the game and its story, impeding future sequels.

Another issue is the control over mod packs.  While gamers develop mods, they often do so with the code and content created by developers, much like writers cribbing from other works or musicians taking riffs from other songs.  However, with mods, gamers have a greater problem than writers.  Large chunks of code, including 3D renderings, gameplay, and soundtracks, are often reused by modders. As a result, true ownership of the mod pack is often in dispute. So when a gamer decides to monetize a mod pack, a developer often has a right to the proceeds of its sales.  Furthermore, should a developer seek to halt the mods distribution, they may have the legal ground to do so.

However, other companies and developers such as Valve, Id (Quake & Doom), Bethseda (Skyrim), and Crytek (Far Cry) have taken a more favorable view of the modding community.  These companies, rather than litigate or restrict gamer access, open their source code up to allow gamers to take control and expand the footprints of games.  One of the biggest examples is Valve and Team Fortress 2.  The game originated from a mod for Quake back in 1996. Valve seized on that gamer centered origin and created Team Fortress 2.  While the game updated every aspect of the previous, the true success of the game lay in the vibrant community modding it allowed and even encouraged.  The tools and equipment unlocked within allowed gamers to design unique outfits and weapons.  Taken in the abstract, the idea of new outfits and weapons seems quite pointless.  However, the game’s popularity has only kept growing, long after the natural lifespan for a video game.  What this popularity does is create strong brand loyalty to Valve.  Valve would further expand on modding with the creation of Steam, an online video game market and modding community.  Steam allows gamers to create and share mods for various games.

It’s encouraging to see Rockstar’s open embrace of the modding community. In the end, it is better for both developers and gamers when they can work together.

One thought on “Modding: The Relationship Between Gamers and Developers

  1. Modding is an odd issue, the line between giving people a bit more variety and just handing them the tools is a fine one.

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s